Is Wine Worth Buying as an Investment

Share:

June 18, 2026 · Siarhei Hamanovich · 4 min read

A bottle can become more valuable without being a good investment for its owner. Purchase price, sale proceeds and the costs between them all matter. Before buying wine to resell, distinguish an index headline from the cash you could actually receive.

Who the secondary market serves

An active resale market exists for a limited selection of collectible wines, not every bottle that improves with age. Demand, producer, vintage, condition and provenance all affect saleability. There is no useful universal percentage of all wine that guarantees “investment grade”.

Do not buy because a producer’s name appears in a price index. Ask what a dealer would pay for that exact vintage and format today, how long a sale might take, and whether you would still want the bottle if resale proved disappointing.

What index numbers do and do not mean

Liv-ex publishes several indices with different constituents. Its Fine Wine 100 is a narrower benchmark than the Fine Wine 1000. A percentage without the index, currency and measurement dates cannot describe “wine” as one investment.

For a dated example, Liv-ex’s 31 October 2026 monthly table reports the Fine Wine 100 at +2.80% over one year and −12.93% over five years. Those are different windows ending on the same date, not contradictory results or a forecast. They do not deduct your personal storage, transaction or tax costs.

The costs to ask about before paying

Ask for the actual storage tariff, insurance coverage, handling and transfer fees. Some warehouses charge per bottle or case rather than as a percentage of collection value, and insurance may already be included. Berry Bros. & Rudd is one example of a provider publishing per-bottle storage charges and included cover; its tariff is not a market-wide rate.

At auction distinguish the estimate, hammer price, buyer’s premium and final invoice. A buyer’s premium is added to the hammer, but the published result may already include it: the Sotheby’s wine-results page cited below explicitly says so. Do not add a premium twice. Rates, taxes and seller charges depend on the auction and contract.

The dealer’s selling price is not necessarily its buying price. That difference is the spread. Get a real bid rather than assuming one fixed spread applies across all wines and vintages.

A calculation without invented net returns

Consider a purely hypothetical purchase for £20,000 and sale ten years later for £35,000, with no intermediate cash flows. The gross gain is 75%, equivalent to about 5.76% annual compound growth: (35,000 / 20,000)^(1/10) − 1. This is arithmetic, not evidence that a Bordeaux collection achieved that return.

To calculate a net internal rate of return, record the dates and amounts of every payment and receipt, including storage, premiums, shipping, insurance, taxes and sale fees. You cannot infer a precise net IRR from a vague “1.5% annual costs” assumption without saying what value it applies to and when it is paid.

Is Wine Worth Buying as an Investment

What the bottle needs to retain resale value

Keep purchase invoices, case identifiers, storage records and transfer documents. The condition of the bottle, fill level, packaging and authenticity can matter as much as the label. Professional storage provides a record, but does not guarantee a sale at an index price.

Bordeaux, Burgundy, Champagne, Italy and California each include wines traded on the secondary market. That does not make every bottle from those places equally liquid. A high price or a long drinking window alone does not create demand.

A sensible decision

Treat potential resale as uncertain. A wine position has carrying costs, physical risks and a sale process that differs from selling a widely traded security. Do not assume low historical correlation means small drawdowns or a reliable future return.

If your main goal is enjoying wine, buy bottles you want to drink and keep records for anything you might later sell. For a financial decision, compare the full cash-flow calculation and risks with your alternatives rather than a cherry-picked index period.

FAQ

Is a published auction result the hammer price?

Not always. Read the result’s definition. Some auction houses publish results including buyer’s premium while excluding taxes and other costs.

Can a 75% gain over ten years be called 7.5% a year?

Not as annual compound growth. With no intermediate cash flows it is about 5.76% gross per year, before any costs.

Does an index show what I can sell my bottle for?

No. Your vintage, format, condition, documentation, fees and available buyers determine your actual proceeds.

Sources and review date

Sources checked on 15 November 2026. Product labels, regulations and prices can change.

Liv-ex: index methodology and definitions

Liv-ex: monthly index close, 31 October 2026

Sotheby’s: buyer’s premium

Sotheby’s: wine auction results and included premiums

Berry Bros. & Rudd: storage service and charges

Similar Posts